The best way to save the rectangles for the sprites in a texture atlas in C#

So while I am writing some code on my Point’n’Click-Adventure-GameEngine (which will be online on GitHub in a few days – hopefully) I suddenly stumble over a small problem: The developer working with the Engine may want to increase performance by putting multiple images into one big textureatlas. But how do I save and access the rectangles in the most performant way?

Using an Array

Obviously one approach would be simply saving it into an array. An array in C# works basically the same way as it does in C: You give it an entry pointer (not entrypoint, that’s something different!) and move it along the length of the saved data to the chunk of bytes that contain the requested object. Definitly the fastest way possible to save and access data. So we are done here. Or are we?

(VSauce music starts playing)

Are there other options?

But of course, there are!

We could use a List, two Lists that are aligned to each other or a Dictionary.

The List itself would be a bad idea, because a List in C# is basically an Array wrapped into another class with some fancy methods built around it.

What about the two Lists? They basically want to be a Dictionary but are not as performant. Let me elaborate:

Imagine two Lists, one contains the keys, the other one contains the values. The keys are saved in List A at the same location as the values in List B, so the following code should give us the desired result:

The problem is: What happens when the key is at the last position in the array? We have to iterate through the whole thing, just to get the key-value connection. This hurts my performance-oriented heart.

So we step to the last type: The Dictionary.

The Dictionary saves the day

First, let me explain how a Dictionary works in C#:

The Dictionary consists of two arrays: The Bucket and the Entries.

These Arrays do basically the same as the two lists in the upper example, but there is a big difference. We save the keys and the values seperatly into collections, but we actually get the data from the Entries-array. Which index we use is determined by the hashcode of the given key. (Source)

Funfact: The Dictionary<TKey, TValue> class in .Net has 1382 lines of code and consists of multiple nested classes and structs. Yet it is rather performant.

After more than 3 entries in the collection the Dictionary<TKey, TValue> surpasses the List<T> when it comes to lookup times. Since the engine targets more than two sprites per atlas (I am optimistic about that), the Dictionary is preferred. (Source)



Go for a Dictionary if you want to be performant, except when you know that a regular array can do the job ofcourse.

Creating a fontsystem

Because in a game it is somewhere required to use a line of text, most game engines are able to process fonts on the fly or on startup. XNA supports so called “spritefonts”, a system that uses xml-files as informationcontainer. These xml-files are saved as “*.spritefont”-file, but even inside they reveal their truth: The first line is an xml-validation.

But xml can’t be used to tell the graphics-processor what to draw, so XNA compiles the information into an xnb-file which is just a collection of bitmaps that are connected to Unicode-Characters. When these characters are called, the font provides the required infomation about them.

The problem is: This system can’t be used on the fly, but in compiletime. And thats the problem. I don’t use the regular contentpipeline. I load my stuff into the engine when I need it, spritefonts don’t support this behaviour.

I had to create my own font-system.

The *.gef-system

I created a system that saves characters into a binary-file followed by bitmaps representing them. I will write an article about the file-architecture sometime, but the current article will be about the creation of the font.

The encoders and the decoder are both extracted from the core-assembly of the game-engine. The reason is simple: I wanted an external tool for the creation of the fonts.

I know there are some simple rules about creating object-oriented assemblies and these tell me that one class has only one job and one purpose. Same goes for the assembly itself. I want to have it as a standalone linked-library. The engine uses the decoder, the tool the encoder, but instead of splitting these up, I create an independent assembly. And there is another thing that I want to mention about the independent assembly: I can update and build it without rebuilding a whole gameengine.

Welcome to my Blog

Hey there! My name is Max, I’m a German Gamedeveloper who is currently working on his B. Sc. in Virtual Reality – Gamedevelopment (and later his M. Sc. in Applied Computer Science).

My greatest interest is the creation of worlds for games and filling them with life (sometimes reffered to as Level- or Contentcreator).

Why don’t you write your own page?
Believe me, It’s not that I hadn’t thought about this. On one hand, sure, it is a nice demonstration of my skills as a developer. I can show that I know how to write and design a website. But on the other hand (let’s face it): Webdevelopment sucks. I don’t like php, I don’t like Javascript. Why should I work with stuff I don’t like, when other people have passion in it and write decent code?

Okay, you don’t like webdevelopment. But why WordPress?
I know there are more Blog-CMS and CMS in general, but since I wan’t to focus on Gamedevelopment and not writing plugins for cms, I chose the most popular cms. It’s not that I don’t like the others, but it seems to be well documented, filled with plugins and it has a nice backend. One thing to mention is the philosophy of wordpress, which I really like: “Code is Poetry”.

Okay, so no webdev, using wordpress, but why a blog?
I like to have a platform which I can use to share my workflow and the things I learned during gamedevelopment. But there is more: I can also express my thoughts about topics which concern me when it comes to anything in games or their development.

Any final words?
Have fun with the things you do. They define you.